What Place has Reason in Divine Commands?
Lesson Objectives
• Understand the relationship between God, covenant, and free will
• Appreciate how DCT claims objectivity and why this is important
• Understand why reasoning is not part of DCT
• Appreciate the inabliity of DCT to be a universal ethical framework
• Understand Euthyphro's Dilemma and its implications
• Appreciate the problems of discerning theological answers without reason
• Appreciate the advantages of Natural Law over DCT
• Understand Aquinas' Seven Basic Goods
• Appreciate the reasons why many modern folks don't agree with Natural Law
Key Terms
Theist
Free Will
Covenant
Divine Command Theory
Atheist
Agnostic
Natural Law Theory
Is/ought problem
Anthropocentrism
God & Morality
The Abrahamic God
• There are many narratives of gods in history
• However, the God of Abraham is claimed to have revealed religion to the patriarch and other prophets (the list varies according to different religions)
• The 3 traditions that came from Abraham are Judaism, Christianity, and Islam
• Those who follow the God of Abraham are "Theists"
• Observant Jews claim God revealed the Torah
• Christians claim God revealed the Old & New Testaments
• Some denominations of Christians (eg. Mormons) claim more scriptures
• Muslims claim God revealed the Quran as His final and corrected scripture
Free Will
• Adherents of the three Abrahamic traditions are understood to have freewill
• Free will is the ability to choose between different moral actions
• Free will is an essential component of the Abrahamic traditions
• In these traditions, obedience is generally not forced but is a free choice
Covenant
• All three traditions claim a covenantal relationship with the God of Abraham
• A covenant is an ancient two-way agreement to which both parties are bound
• In this, adherents are compelled to obey God in order to recieve His blessing