Is there only one right way?
Lesson Objectives
Appreciate the Grounding Problem for Ethical questions
Appreciate the diversity of Moral Realist positions
Understand the difference between Ethical Monism & Ethical Pluralism
Appreciate what it might take to return to Kantian Ethics in a plural way
Understand how Ross' Prima Facie Duties work in a pluralist way
Appreciate the problems of treating all moral problems as unique
Key Terms
The Grounding Problem
Moral Realism
Moral Antirealism
Moral Absolutism
Moral Relativism
Cultural Relativism
Ethical Monism
Ethical Pluralism
Prima Facie Duties
Ethical Particularism
An Introduction to Metaethics
Moral Realism
• There ARE moral facts in the universe, just like scientific facts
• In Moral Realism, any moral claim is either true or false
• But what is the basis of moral facts?
• What is their source? Are they testable? Falsifiable?
The "Grounding Problem" of Ethics
• What is the foundation of our moral beliefs?
• It'd be fantastic if there was something solid we use as a foundation for our moral claims (eg. like math or science)
Moral Antirealism
• There ARE NO moral facts — just opinions and traditions
• It is foolish to imagine morality as an objective enterprise
• So, there's nothing 'inherently wrong' about anything